Receiving an offer on your home is exciting—but what happens when you receive more than one? Even if it’s just a single offer, understanding how to evaluate it thoroughly is critical to your success as a seller.
This guide breaks down everything you need to know about reviewing home purchase offers, from comparing contingencies to spotting red flags, so you can make a confident, informed decision.
1. Understand the Basics of a Purchase Offer
A home offer isn’t just a price—it’s a detailed contract outlining terms, timelines, and conditions. Offers typically include the purchase price, proposed closing date, deposit amount, financing terms, and any contingencies.
Make sure you understand each component and how it affects your bottom line, your timeline, and your risk. Review the purchase agreement in full before making a decision, and consult with your agent to translate legal language.
2. Compare Price, But Look Beyond It
Naturally, you’ll be drawn to the highest offer—but that isn’t always the best one. Some offers may come with financing challenges, a long list of contingencies, or unrealistic timelines.
Consider how “clean” the offer is. A slightly lower bid with fewer complications or a faster close might actually get you to your goals more reliably.
3. Review the Earnest Money Deposit
Earnest money is the buyer’s good-faith deposit, usually 1-3% of the home price. It shows the buyer’s commitment and protects you if they back out without cause.
Higher earnest money deposits often signal serious intent, which can make an offer more appealing, especially in a competitive market.
4. Evaluate Buyer Financing
Is the buyer paying in cash or using financing? Cash offers are generally preferred—they close faster and carry less risk of falling through.
If the buyer is using a mortgage, review whether they’re pre-approved, not just pre-qualified. A pre-approval letter gives you more confidence that they can actually secure the funds.
5. Understand Contingencies
Contingencies are conditions the buyer must meet before closing. These can include inspections, appraisal, loan approval, and selling their current home.
Too many contingencies can introduce delays or potential cancellations. Offers with fewer contingencies (or none at all) are stronger and more likely to close smoothly.
6. Compare Closing Timelines
How soon does the buyer want to close? Your ideal closing date may not align with theirs, especially if you’re still looking for your next home.
Make sure the timeline works for you. If you need to stay in the home post-close, consider negotiating a rent-back period.
7. Watch for Seller Concessions
Some buyers will ask the seller to pay part of their closing costs, repair credits, or include furnishings or appliances. These requests reduce your net proceeds.
Factor in any seller-paid costs when comparing offers. The highest offer might not net you the most money after concessions.
8. Analyze Offer Strength in Competitive Markets
If you’re in a hot market, buyers may submit offers with escalation clauses, waiving contingencies, or even personal letters. These tactics can help set them apart.
Escalation clauses can drive up the price but be sure to cap them to avoid unrealistic bidding. Emotional appeal should never outweigh financial and legal stability.
9. Consider Your Personal Goals
Sometimes, the best offer isn’t just about money. Maybe you want a quicker close, a buyer who will take care of your home, or less post-sale stress.
Talk with your agent about your goals, both financial and personal. Your ideal offer will balance what matters most to you.
10. Make a Counteroffer If Needed
You’re not obligated to accept an offer as-is. You can counter on price, closing date, contingencies, or any term you’re not satisfied with.
A skilled agent can help you negotiate terms that meet your needs while keeping the buyer engaged.
11. Accepting the Offer
Once you’ve reviewed all the details and feel confident, you can accept the offer in writing. This turns the offer into a legally binding contract.
After acceptance, the transaction moves into escrow and due diligence, where inspections, appraisals, and financing will finalize.
12. When to Reject an Offer
If an offer feels risky, too complicated, or simply doesn’t meet your goals, you can reject it. Be prompt and professional in your response.
A rejection can often lead to a revised offer from the buyer if they’re truly interested in the home.
13. Use Your Agent’s Expertise
Your real estate agent has likely reviewed hundreds of offers and can point out what you might miss. Their guidance is invaluable, especially in multiple-offer scenarios.
Lean on their experience to avoid pitfalls and secure the strongest deal possible.
Conclusion
Choosing the right offer is one of the most important decisions you’ll make as a home seller. Take your time, ask questions, and don’t rush—your patience can pay off in thousands of dollars and peace of mind.
.avif){kind=spacer}